On an early August night, Detroit's Fillmore (formerly The State Theatre), hosted an amazing indie-alternative double bill and reunion of Tomahawk and Melvins! These groups graced Detroit with a performance on their infamous Geek Show tour in 2003 and were back this summer to celebrate the 25th anniversary of Tomahawk's formation and debut album. In spite of the theme, fans were surprised (pleasantly or not) to be treated to a set mostly focused on the band's fifth and most recent LP, 2021s Tonic Immobility, an album for which they never toured as it was completed and released during the COVID shut down.
After an unadvertised opening set from thereminist Ni Maitres, the legendary Washington-based sludge-metal legends Melvins took the stage to a warm welcome from the audience and immediately launched into "Working the Ditch," establishing that the volume would be blisteringly loud and that movement in the GA pit in front of the stage would be in full effect in spite of most in the crowd being in their 40s and 50s (and most of the performers approaching or already in their 60s), much to the surprise of some who expected a less physical show than the bands' 2003 tour. Rocking nearly continuously for an hour, Melvins mixed a handful of '80s and '90s classics ("Honey Bucket," "Hag Me," "The Bit," and "It's Shoved") with 21st century material and an especially noisy cover of The Rolling Stones' "Sway" which was completely unrecognizable compared to the original, even for avid Stones fans. In addition to founder Buzz Osbourne (guitar/vocals) and longtime drummer Dale Crover, the band also featured Steven Shane McDonald on bass and second drummer Coady Willis, each lending to the cacophony of joyously doomy racket contained throughout the set. Tomahawk bassist Trevor Dunn, himself a former member of Melvins, joined the band on their closing number, "Night Goat" adding a second layer of bottom end to McDonald's and at one point, literally fencing with the necks of their basses during the song.
Following an average-length set change, Tomahawk took the stage and began with "Flashback," the opening track from their self-titled debut, which immediately stirred the pit right back up and engaged all in attendance. From there, the band began to lean heavily into songs from Tonic Immobility, running through four in a row ("SHHH!," "Predators and Scavengers," "Business Casual," and "Doomsday Fatigue") and eventually performing nine of the 12 tracks from that album. While their newer songs (odd to say considering they are five years old now) sit well next to their classic material, it was clear to see the effect on the crowd was lessened until they returned to tracks like "Rape This Day," "Birdsong" and "Capt. Midnight" from 2003's Mit Gas, which was arguably the strongest section of the night.
The second half of Tomahawk's show continued to alternate between Tonic Immobility tracks and pieces from their third and fourth albums, such as "South Paw," "I.O.U." and "White Hats/Black Hats" from 2013's Oddfellows during one section and a brief nod to 2007's Anonymous with a performance of "Totem" near the end of the main set, which concluded with "Point and Click" from the debut album. Vocalist/keyboardist Mike Patton commanded the stage and led the band with focused precision throughout and playfully interacted with the crowd in his traditionally deprecating style here and there between songs. Bassist Trevor Dunn and drummer John Stainer maintained a tight rhythm and varied dynamic throughout, and guitarist Duane Denison received notable attention from the audience during standout moments, especially on the band's earliest songs.
After a short encore break, Tomahawk returned to perform a cover of Duane Eddy's "Stalkin'" and their own "Rise Up Dirty Waters" and "God Hates a Coward," featuring the return of Patton's gas mask microphone. It was the most engaging track of the night and not coincidentally saved until the very end where it inspired the most movement and physical interaction among the audience.
At some point, the combination of talent that makes up a supergroup, whether the members are well known as individuals or not, gets lost in the product of their collaboration. In this case, decades of experience writing, recording, and touring with Faith No More, Mr. Bungle, Helmet, The Jesus Lizard, Red Kross, OFF! and many others resulted in a professional execution from veteran players who seem most at home when performing their songs to their crowds (rather than introducing people to them as opening acts on a bigger tour or at a festival). The legacy of talent and the continuing dedication of players who have been hitting it hard for 40 years or more comes through at a show like this, especially compared to younger, modern acts. Whether this summer's tour was a final victory lap for Tomahawk or a reigniting of the creativity within the project remains to be seen, but everyone who appeared with both bands will undoubtedly be back around again soon, either with their main projects or even new side projects that are just getting started!
Melvins set list (8/3/26):
Working the Ditch
Never Say You're Sorry
Sway (The Rolling Stones)
Evil New War God
Civilized Worm
It's Shoved
A History of Bad Men
The Bit
Blood Witch
Hag Me
Honey Bucket
Night Goat (w/Trevor Dunn)
----------------------------
Tomahawk set list (8/3/26):
Elmer Bernstein-"Clark Street: The Top" (intro tape)
---------------
Flashback
SHHH!
Predators and Scavengers
Business Casual
Doomsday Fatigue
Rape This Day
Eureka
Birdsong/Juan in the Garden (Robert Crosbie)
Capt. Midnight
Howlie
Recoil
South Paw
I.O.U.
White Hats/Black Hats
Fatback
Sidewinder
Totem
Point and Click
-----------------
Stalkin' (Duane Eddy)
Rise Up Dirty Waters
God Hates a Coward
---------------
Jimmy Van Heusen-"All the Way" (outro tape)
********************************************
*Follow Jamblog by subscribing on the home page, by following our facebook page, or both!
*For even more, don't forget to also like and follow our music video and live performance page for great music from all of rock history in your timeline every day!!* https://www.facebook.com/rocknrollhst/







